Your Obedient Serpent (athelind) wrote,
Your Obedient Serpent
athelind

  • Mood:

The Hoard Potato on Dollhouse, sight seen.

quelonzia and I just watched the first 45 minutes of Dollhouse.

We didn't bother with the last 15.

The MacGuffin for the pilot episode was a hostage negotiation. If they'd done the same "engagement" on Burn Notice or Leverage, there would have been a lot less twiddling, and a lot more Smart People Doing Smart Things, quite possibly punctuated by explosions. Even a fairly mundane police procedural like Law & Order would have mustered more tension.

Sure, this was a pilot, and had to spend some time to establish the premise -- but My Own Worst Enemy hit the ground running in its opener, while presenting an equally-complex, somewhat less "arty" premise in a way that should be the textbook chapter of "show, don't tell".

Our combined assessment: Joss is too in love with his Brilliant Idea to actually tell a story with it.

I, on the other claw, have been "meh" about that premise since I first heard about it months ago.

I keep thinking that maybe I'm just disappointed because it was so hyped up, and didn't measure up to the hype -- but, frankly, if Joss Whedon's name hadn't been attached to it, I wouldn't have bothered to tune in in the first place.

And now I won't.


Oh, and I'm sorry if I was too busy being bored to notice if Dollhouse was "sexist".
By the way, you can watch all 9 episodes of My Own Worst Enemy at NBC's web site. Ding DING ding.

Tags: hoard potato, science, sf, television, tv
Subscribe

  • In Which Your Obedient Serpend SHUTS THE TWEET UP

    I have disabled the Twitter Aggregate Post Function on LiveJournal. It has done nothing but spam my archive and make it impossible for me to find…

  • My tweets

    Tue, 12:17: RT @ WIRED: Patch your Chrysler now against a wireless hacking attack http://t.co/jLc4nDNxVV Tue, 12:17: RT @ karldegre:…

  • My tweets

    Mon, 14:06: RT @ usclimateplan: California's #climate goals could catapult the state economy forward while setting new global standards.…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 5 comments