Your Obedient Serpent (athelind) wrote,
Your Obedient Serpent
athelind

The Hoard Potato rags on Dungeon Fantasy some more.

paka posted some thoughts on LotR Elves vs. D&D Elves, in which he noted that Unca Gary wasn't that much of a Tolkien fan, since the Professor's work "wasn't pulpy enough for his tastes".

I responded:
I have long felt that the reason Dungeon Fantasy mutated into its own peculiar, inbred subgenre that, frankly, doesn't really WORK that well was because players tried to graft the tropes of Heroic Quest Fantasy onto a system whose initial assumptions were rooted in the very different tropes of picaresque Sword & Sorcery.


I may be the only person who thinks so anymore, but to me, D&D's haphazard combination of High Fantasy and Sword & Sorcery isn't so much a matter of "you got peanut butter in my chocolate" as "you're wearing plaid and paisley together."


Tags: dungeon fantasy, fantasy, gaming, grognard, metaquoted, rpg, sword & sorcery
Subscribe

  • State of the Dragon: ... and THEN ...

    ... an hour after my last post, I was in the ER for chest pains. An overnight stay, lots of bloodwork, and a treadmill exam, and the cardiologist…

  • YULE!

    Your Obedient Serpent flew his mother and stepfather up for the holidays. They're currently staying with his sister. A very pleasant holiday was…

  • Random Thoughts from a Sick Mind

    ... "sick mind" as in "staying home sick today with weird sinus-related wooziness", which is leaving my brain making strange, dissociated, random…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 11 comments

  • State of the Dragon: ... and THEN ...

    ... an hour after my last post, I was in the ER for chest pains. An overnight stay, lots of bloodwork, and a treadmill exam, and the cardiologist…

  • YULE!

    Your Obedient Serpent flew his mother and stepfather up for the holidays. They're currently staying with his sister. A very pleasant holiday was…

  • Random Thoughts from a Sick Mind

    ... "sick mind" as in "staying home sick today with weird sinus-related wooziness", which is leaving my brain making strange, dissociated, random…